Page 1 of 5

Whammy won't stay in tune.

Posted: Fri Aug 03, 2012 1:51 am
by SanchoPansen
Hello and thanks for the help ;-)
Like said in my introduction I do own an original Mark V and I bought a Dana Mark I 2 weeks ago.
Now the Dana model plays well and I really like it, but the whammy won't stay in tune. When I pull it up it just stays there.
When I press it down it won't come back to the right spot. I'm not firm with machines (I work at a bank) and I'm just a player.
The only thing I could do is to apply some oil to some parts, so it won't be so sticky any more. But before doing so I thought I might check with you guys as you all seem to have way more experience than I have.
This is where I think I could apply some oil in order to make the whammy go up and down smoother (sorry for stealing the pic - someone stole my mobile and I'm too lazy to pick up my camera):
Image
Is it okay to put some oil on the joints? Or will the whammy go crazy after that? Thanks in advance folks ;-)
It came exquipped with really thin strings (I usually play .011 or more). Could changing the strings to a heavier gauge help the whammy to stay in tune?
Oh and I just pulled a trigger on a 60 custom! I will be a proud owner of a Semie, Dana and Bob model! Darn, that feels good!

Cheers
Sancho

Re: Whammy won't stay in tune.

Posted: Fri Aug 03, 2012 2:22 am
by Veenture
Sancho, I have a feeling that the problem area could be the wammy bar's coil spring, itself. I had the same problem with my Kurokumo Mosrite. I replaced the original spring with my reserve "Hallmark" spring (slightly heavier/longer, I think) and the problem was solved. You could also try s-t-r-e-t-c-h-i-n-g your coil spring a bit. Good luck.

-Paul

Re: Whammy won't stay in tune.

Posted: Fri Aug 03, 2012 6:05 am
by SanchoPansen
Hey thanks for the fast reply. That sounds plausible. I'll check that option as well. For the time I wait for a new spring, does anyone know if a little oil or WD40 would help or rather damage the joints?! Just don't want to ruin the guitar...

Re: Whammy won't stay in tune.

Posted: Fri Aug 03, 2012 9:27 am
by vibramutant1965
Take the strings off the tuners, remove the spring, and make sure there is no binding "unloaded". Put the spring in and try it again, the spring is probably getting hung up on the arms fastener. I remember having to grind the nut smaller(hex) on one of my mosrites.

Re: Whammy won't stay in tune.

Posted: Sun Aug 05, 2012 7:24 am
by SanchoPansen
Okay, I disassembled the whole system today without success... :evil:
I'll try to describe what I did:
First I changed the spring. I had an old spring (noname) lying around here. Same issue -> I use the Vibramute by pressing, I jumps back to the correct position. I bend it up, it stays almost one note (E becomes F) above the original position.
So the spring doesn't seem to cause the problem (well, maybe it does and the cheapo spring is having the same issue - there are things like coincidences...).
I also pulled out the bolt inside the system, cleaned it and put some WD40 on it. Next thing was making sure that the nut isn't hanging on the spring. First I removed one of the washers so the nut goes further up. Didn't help. Next I took out the whole arm. Same issue: pull it up and it stays there.
Then I discovered that the whole system had contact with each other at some point. So I removed some material and pushed it further down. The issue remains the same. Here's a picture of the part I mean:
Image
I discovered 2 more things that I found a little bit disturbing. The G-string roller won't roll (seems like the part has been pushed together). It can be moved, but it won't roll on it's own. I removed the G-string to be sure that this isn't an issue and yes, the problem remains...here's a picture:
Image
The 2nd thing that caught my attention was the space between the roller bridge and the pickup:
Image
It's hard to tell if these parts do have contact or not. I might try a different nut or rasping a little bit off the original one, just to be sure. So that's what I did for the last 3 hours or so and it still won't stay in tune. Hopefully it is something that can be fixed easily, as I don't know what to do any more...any kind of help is really appreciated. :cry:

Re: Whammy won't stay in tune.

Posted: Sun Aug 05, 2012 9:28 am
by MWaldorf
My guess is that the string guide contacting the base plate is the issue. Try putting a nylon or teflon washer in between the two parts to reduce friction.

Re: Whammy won't stay in tune.

Posted: Sun Aug 05, 2012 9:30 am
by FritzCat
This sounds like a classic nut binding situation, even though Mosrites have a zero fret and string guide in place of a nut. I would make sure the strings aren't binding in the string guide, and also lube the string guide as well as the zero fret where the strings make contact.

Re: Whammy won't stay in tune.

Posted: Sun Aug 05, 2012 11:05 am
by SanchoPansen
Teflon washers...check! (Could have thought of this as well ;-) I feel embarrassed now)
Checking the other side of the neck seems also plausible. Any recommendations regarding the lube? Vaseline?!

Re: Whammy won't stay in tune.

Posted: Sun Aug 05, 2012 1:53 pm
by ludobag
for me you have lot of friction point that s why it doesn' stay in tune
the rocking part like you said ,maybe in the string guide (string same as when you buy the guitar or more highter gauge ?)
as i see your bridge is not really flat too ,maybe it move a little, moreover if it have a contact with the pups (you can try to put it upside down maybe the head screws doesn't touch the pups?)
the roller of bridge who doesn't roll ect ....
take it point by point to find the friction
if there is no friction normally it will stay in tune
maybe you have to pull down the bar for it
and other thing i have just think what brand of string do you use maybe some are defective ? (i have buy month ago sets who have always E treble who broke after there are mount and one time i have same trouble with the D string )

Re: Whammy won't stay in tune.

Posted: Sun Aug 05, 2012 3:02 pm
by Veenture
The G-string roller won't roll (seems like the part has been pushed together).
To get it rolling again, try using a piece of string by pulling it to and fro on the roller as a pulley, much like a car's fan belt turning the fan.